Alternative medicine popular in Canada: survey
| | |
Fraser Institute – More than half of Canadians surveyed in 2006 reported using at least one form of complementary or alternative medicine or treatment during the previous year, according to a new report published today by independent research organization, The Fraser Institute.
The report, Complementary and Alternative Medicine in Canada: Trends in Use and Public Attitudes, 1997-2006, is based on a survey of 2,000 adult Canadians conducted in 2006. It follows up on a similar survey done in 1997.
The survey showed 54% of respondents used at least one form of alternative or complementary therapy in the year prior to the survey, an increase of four percentage points over the 1997 result of 50%.
“This increased use of alternative therapies is another indicator of Canadians’ desire to have more choice and control over their health care options,” said Nadeem Esmail, The Fraser Institute’s Director of Health System Performance and author of the report.
The most commonly used complementary and alternative medicines and therapies reported were massage (19%), prayer (16%), chiropractic care (15%), relaxation techniques (14%), and herbal therapies (10%).
Most users of alternative therapies said they did so to prevent future illness from occurring or to maintain health and vitality. Of those who used alternative medicine in the 12 months prior to the 2006 survey, 53% of respondents (down slightly from 56% in 1997) had not discussed their use of alternative medicine with their doctor.
On a provincial basis, Alberta saw the largest increase in the use of alternative therapies in the year previous to the 2006 survey (68% compared to 54% in 1997), followed by Ontario (55% compared to 50% in 1997), and British Columbia (64% from 60% in 1997). Quebec and Saskatchewan/ Manitoba both experienced a 1% increase, moving from 44 to 45 and from 58 to 59% respectively, while Atlantic Canada experienced a decrease in the use of alternative therapies, falling to 39% in 2006 from 45% in 1997.
Despite the increased use of alternative medicine, the majority of Canadians still consider medical doctors the main providers of health care with almost half of respondents in 2006 seeing a doctor before turning to a provider of alternative therapy. Additionally, a higher proportion of respondents saw a medical doctor for their condition regarding treatment for eight of the 10 most common medical conditions.
“These results show Canadians retain confidence in physicians. But since many of the most common problems Canadians suffer from are chronic – allergies, back or neck problems, arthritis and rheumatism – they require more than just symptomatic treatment. Consequently, Canadians are looking for alternatives,” Esmail said.
What is interesting, he added, is that most alternative and complementary treatments are not covered by government health insurance plans. Yet a large number of people choose those options.
“When it comes to health and well-being, a significant number of Canadians are willing to spend their own money.”
Esmail estimates that Canadians spent approximately $7.8 billion out of pocket on alternative medicine in the year before the 2006 survey — a significant increase from the nearly $5.4 billion (inflation-adjusted) spent in 1997. In 2006, more than $5.6 billion was spent on providers of alternative therapy, while another $2.2 billion was spent on herbs, vitamins, special diet programs, books, classes and equipment.
But the survey also shows the majority of Canadians (59%) believe that alternative therapies should be paid for privately, not by provincial health plans. The highest level of support for private payment came from the group that used alternative therapy the most: 58% of 18- to 34-year-olds used alternative therapies in the 12 months prior to the 2006 survey, and 62% of them preferred that individuals pay for it privately.
Regionally, support for private payment in 2006 was strongest in Quebec and Saskatchewan/Manitoba (66%) and weakest in Atlantic Canada (50%). This is a notable change from 1997 when support was strongest in Atlantic Canada (71%) and weakest in British Columbia (48%).
“In 2006, 74% of Canadians say they have used alternative therapies at some point in their lifetimes, and more than half of Canadians have used alternative therapies in the year prior to the survey,” Esmail said.
“However, there are some notable differences between the regions in Canada with respect to both use and attitudes towards alternative medicine. Albertans and British Columbians are more likely to see value in alternative therapies while skepticism reigns in Atlantic Canada. A national consensus on this issue is highly improbable.”